Fake invoice? How to check if a bill is real
A fake invoice (in Dutch: spookfactuur) is a bill for something you never ordered, or an offer dressed up as an invoice. If your own records show no order and no contract, do not pay: the sender has to be able to prove there is an agreement with you, and without that proof you are not obliged to pay.
The Fraudehelpdesk, the Dutch fraud helpline, sees two kinds. The disguised offer looks like an invoice, but the small print says it is an offer, so paying it is exactly what creates the contract. The invoice without an order bills you for something nobody asked for. According to the helpdesk, sending either one is a criminal offence.
The Dutch police treat these bills as acquisitiefraude (acquisition fraud): charging for things that were never ordered or delivered. The bait varies: a listing in a directory or “register”, a domain name, a trademark registration. Often a phone call comes first. A copy of a real supplier’s invoice with a different bank account is something else: see the guide on CEO and invoice fraud.
How to spot it
- 1You never ordered it.No order, contract or contact person in your records, and the invoice number matches nothing. These bills are often for small amounts and carry a familiar company name, so nobody is alarmed (KVK, the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce).
- 2The small print says “offer”.At the bottom, small and grey: paying means accepting a contract.
- 3The name sounds like an authority or a register.For comparison: KVK never sends invoices for an annual contribution to the Business Register, and the EU trademark office EUIPO never sends users invoices or payment requests for services.
- 4A domain or trademark letter from a company you do not know.“Someone else wants your name with .com or .info, but you have priority.” That “right of first registration” does not exist, and a domain name normally costs 4 to 15 euros a year (KVK). The same trick is played with trademarks (Fraudehelpdesk, October 2024).
- 5First a phone call, then the bill.“You were already listed with us”, “could you just confirm your details?” Sign or say “yes” afterwards and it turns out you have a contract. KVK and the Fraudehelpdesk: always say no to phone offers and make no verbal commitments.
- 6Pressure, threats or a debt collector.“Pay within 8 days or lose your domain name”, or a collection letter that does not say what the debt is. The Fraudehelpdesk calls that kind of letter a fake invoice too.
A real example, taken apart
- There is no order, and the sender is not your registrar. The SIDN whois shows who is.
- The threat of “losing your domain name” is there to rush you. You renew with your own registrar.
- €289 a year, while a domain name normally costs 4 to 15 euros a year (KVK).
- The small print makes it an offer: paying is what creates the agreement (Fraudehelpdesk).
What you do
- Check it against your own records.Look for the order, the contract or the contact person. Nothing there? Then you do not pay.
- Do not pay, and ask for proof in writing.Ask what the invoice is based on and say that without proof of an agreement you will not pay. Sign nothing and agree to nothing by phone or e-mail. In doubt? Contact the supplier through the details in your own records, never the ones on the invoice.
- Already said “yes” or signed?The terms sometimes let you cancel within 24 hours or a few days. If not, object by registered letter and ask for the contract to be declared invalid. Ask for the call recording, keep every letter and e-mail, and bring in a lawyer if you need one (KVK).
- Already paid? Call your bank straight away.The payment can sometimes still be reversed (KVK). Report it to the police.
- Report it.The Dutch police say: always report it. You can do so on 0900-8844. Also report it to the Fraudehelpdesk, through its online form (choose to report on behalf of your business; the site is in Dutch) or on 088 - 7867372. They give advice and warn other businesses.
- Make it a house rule.Only pay against an order in your own system, always say no to offers made over the phone, and tell your staff how these tricks work.
Never do this
- Pay because it says “invoice”, “reminder” or “final notice”.
- Say “yes” on the phone or “just confirm” your details.
- Sign and return a form or e-mail without reading the small print.
Questions people ask
Is this invoice real? How do I check quickly?
Did you order it, with an order or contract in your records? Do you know the sender as a supplier? Does the bank account match the one you paid before? If any answer is no, do not pay, and contact the supplier through your own details.
I got an invoice for my domain name from a company I do not know. Do I have to pay?
No, not without an agreement. You renew your domain with your own registrar; for .nl domains the SIDN whois shows who that is. A letter or e-mail from anyone else is at most an offer.
Are fake invoices illegal in the Netherlands?
According to the Fraudehelpdesk, yes: both the disguised offer and the invoice without an order. Whether your case is fraud in the legal sense depends on the details. The Dutch police say: always report it (0900-8844).
A debt collector is chasing me now. Do I have to pay?
Not if there is no agreement: the sender has to be able to prove one. Do not let yourself be pressured, put your position in writing and ask a lawyer for advice.
Does KVK send an annual invoice for my registration?
No. KVK never sends invoices for an annual contribution to the Business Register. KVK’s own invoices page lists the details that belong on a genuine KVK invoice.
My bank showed a green tick on the name check. So the invoice is real?
No. The IBAN-Name Check only tells you that the name and the account number belong together. A fake invoice often comes from a company that really exists and has a real account. The tick says nothing about whether you owe anything.
Paste it into the checker. Thirty seconds, and you know what others already saw.
Read next
Sources
Fraudehelpdesk — Fake invoices (spookfacturen, in Dutch) · Fraudehelpdesk — Acquisition fraud (in Dutch) · Fraudehelpdesk — Trademark scam aimed at businesses, Oct 2024 (in Dutch) · Fraudehelpdesk — Fake invoice from a “collection agency” (in Dutch) · Fraudehelpdesk — Report fraud (in Dutch) · KVK — Check your bill: do not fall for invoice fraud · KVK — How to avoid acquisition fraud · KVK — Unsolicited sales of domain names: do not fall for it · KVK — Did KVK really send this email? · KVK — Invoices from KVK (in Dutch) · Business.gov.nl — Reporting fraud and deception · Politie — What is acquisition fraud? (in Dutch) · Politie — Reporting acquisition fraud (in Dutch) · SIDN — What is invoice fraud with fake domain names? · SIDN — Whois: who manages a .nl domain · EUIPO — Misleading invoices · Dutch Payments Association — IBAN-Name Check